Teaching with Web
Sites
Copyright © Adam Waxler
www.teaching-teacher.com
In her article,
"Kathy Schrock's Guide for Educators", Schrock provides just that, a
guide for teachers to use for themselves and with their students to
evaluate web sites.
As the Internet
continues to grow and with web sites based on anything from
commercial advertising to personal opinions to simply doling out
incorrect information, Schrock stresses the importance of both
teacher and student to be able to critically evaluate web sites.
Schrock suggests three basic areas of evaluation. The first area of
evaluation is navigation and usability. To put simply, the web site
should be easy to use. The site should have a site map as well as
links to other sites. The second area is authorship. The site user
should be able to find out information about the author and what
makes him or her a credible authority on the particular subject.
Schrock's third area of evaluating web sites is content validity.
The emphasis in this third area involves not just the legitimacy of
the content, but being able to decipher between commercial, opinion,
and fact.
Based on her three
areas of evaluating web sites, Kathy Schrock has put together
evaluation instruments for the elementary, middle, and secondary
school levels. The evaluation process involves students working in
groups with each group receiving edited versions of the same web
site. Students then work together to point out the plusses and
minuses of the edited versions. As Schrock points out, this
evaluation process not only teaches students how to evaluate web
sites, but also teaches them higher-order thinking skills that carry
over into other lessons and projects.
While Kathy
Schrock's purpose of the article is to stress the importance of
teachers and students to critically evaluate web sites, she
emphasizes that her intent is not for them to exclude certain
sites, but rather to be aware of what the purpose of a particular
site is and therefore be able to use it wisely.
References
Schrock, K.
(1998. March). Kathy Schrock's Guide for Educators. Internet
Trend Watch for Libraries.
Adam
Waxler is a middle school social studies teacher, teacher mentor,
and the author of eTeach: A Teacher Resource for Learning the
Strategies of Master Teachers. Adam is also the
editor and publisher of The Teaching Teacher’s Newsletter.
For more information about his ebook or to sign up for your free
monthly newsletter log onto:
http://www.teaching-teacher.com
|